Skip to content
All articles
Law & regulation 8 min read· by Lars Zimmermann

AI as a tax adviser? Why the liability stays with you

ChatGPT is happy to give tax tips. But the AI is not liable, is not bound to secrecy and may not advise. Why the responsibility stays with you in the end.

In short

An AI such as ChatGPT readily gives tax tips, but it is not liable, is not bound to confidentiality and may not advise commercially in Germany at all. The reservation of tax advice to licensed professions protects exactly that. Whoever passes AI tax tips to the tax office unchecked is liable themselves, because “the AI said so” is no excuse.

Auf Deutsch lesen: deutsche Fassung

AI is sold to me again and again as a jack of all trades, and recently the sentence came up: you no longer need a tax adviser, ChatGPT does that now. You type in your figures, and the AI tells you how to save tax. I have a tax adviser myself, and I know exactly why. An AI readily gives tax tips, that is true. Only it is not liable, it does not keep secrets, and in Germany it may not advise on a commercial basis at all. This is my assessment as an auditor, not tax or legal advice: anyone who uses AI in tax matters should know where the responsibility stays. Namely with them.

Why tax advice is a reserved profession

Tax advice is not a free market in Germany. The Tax Advisory Act (Steuerberatungsgesetz, StBerG) governs who may assist in tax matters on a commercial basis: tax advisers, lawyers, auditors and a few others. Anyone who is not among them may not do so, and unauthorised assistance in tax matters is expressly prohibited. That sounds like guild thinking, but it is a protection for you.

Because behind a tax adviser there is more than knowledge. He is liable for his mistakes and insured for them. He is bound to confidentiality, backed by criminal sanctions. And he knows your case, not just a text pattern. An AI is none of that. It is not an authorised adviser, it has no professional indemnity insurance, and it answers for nothing. The professional reservation draws exactly this line.

For companies this is more than a side note. Payroll, advance VAT returns, annual financial statements: this is precisely where tools advertise that they will take care of the tax as well. The professional reservation and the liability do not disappear as a result. An entrepreneur who delegates the binding tax work to a tool and has no adviser behind it has not handed over the responsibility, only the control.

For your own tax you may, but you alone are liable

Importantly, so that no misunderstanding arises: you may of course do your own tax return yourself, with or without AI. The professional reservation concerns commercial assistance for others, not your own affairs. But anyone who builds or offers an AI tool that gives third parties tax information on a commercial basis is moving at the edge of what is permitted.

For you as a user it still means: nobody stands behind the advice. If you adopt an AI tax tip unchecked in your return and it is wrong, you are liable. Towards the tax office it does not matter where the information came from. Incorrect information can be a reckless understatement of tax (Section 378 of the German Fiscal Code, Abgabenordnung, AO), and in the case of intent even tax evasion (Section 370). The sentence “the AI said so” is not an excuse the tax office accepts.

Information is not yet advice

A distinction is worthwhile here that blurs in everyday life: information is not yet advice. An AI can explain to you what an investment deduction is. That is information, freely available as in any textbook. Whether it is permissible, sensible and correctly calculated in your specific case, that is advice. The difference is not academic. Advice means: someone looks at your case, applies the rule to it and stands behind it with their liability.

It is exactly this second half that the AI cannot deliver. It does not know your turnover, your history, or the tax audit from three years ago. It gives you a general pattern and sounds as if it were your case. Anyone who confuses the two confuses the map with the road.

The AI invents tax advantages that do not exist

Tax law is the worst conceivable place for a technology that sounds convincing and can still be wrong. That is exactly what language models do: they predict the likely next word, not the verified truth. With taxes they then invent allowances that do not exist, deadlines that have long since passed, or sections that never existed.

This is not a theoretical risk. In one well-known case a lawyer submitted judgments to a court that an AI had made up entirely, with case numbers and everything. Transferred to tax: the AI names a deduction that sounds plausible and does not exist. You enter it, the tax office strikes it out, and in the worst case the suspicion arises that you should have known better. Tax law changes every year. A model with yesterday’s state of knowledge gives you the rules of the day before yesterday.

An example from everyday business: you ask the AI whether you can fully deduct the Christmas party, and you get a clear yes with a figure. Reality is more fine-grained. There is an allowance per participating employee, it concerns wage tax and depends on conditions, and both change over the years. If you rely on the quick yes, you post it wrongly, and the mistake only comes to light in the audit, then with interest.

A misunderstanding often resonates here: guided tax software is not the same as an AI chatbot. Classic tax programs lead you through the forms in a structured way, with verified calculation logic and fixed fields. A freely chatting chatbot, by contrast, tells you what sounds likely. Both carry the label “AI” today, but one follows rules, the other guesses. If you use a tool, you should know which category it plays in.

When the AI advises into the grey area

There is a variant that is more delicate than the honest mistake: the tip that is too good. If you ask boldly enough, such a model will also come out with arrangements that sound tempting and reach into the grey area, from the creative allocation of private costs to constructions that smell more like tax avoidance at any price. The AI does not ask whether that suits you, and it does not warn you where legal structuring ends.

Legal tax structuring is permitted, that is an important distinction. But the line is fine, and knowing it is the core of the profession. A tax adviser tells you where it stops, and he is liable if he is wrong. The AI does not tell you, and if the tax office later takes a different view, you sit there alone. A tip that sounds too good to be true is rarely a gift in tax matters and often a risk.

Your financial data does not belong in an open AI tool

And then there is the question hardly anyone asks: what actually happens to your figures once you type them in? Anyone who tips receipts, turnover and account data into a free, public AI tool hands sensitive financial data to an outside provider, often in a third country, without a contract and without confidentiality.

Here too the comparison with the tax adviser shows the difference. He is subject to a duty of confidentiality, the breach of which is punishable under Section 203 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB). A public language model is not subject to it. For companies there is more: if client, personnel or business data ends up in an unvetted tool, that is a data protection breach waiting to happen, regardless of whether a good tax tip comes out at the end.

In concrete terms: an employee uploads the payroll list to a free AI tool to have it evaluated quickly. At that moment names, salaries and social security data have left your company, to a provider nobody has vetted. Whether the AI then gives a usable tip is secondary. The damage has already been done, and it cannot be undone.

What AI can really do in tax matters

I am not against AI in tax. I am against AI without control and without an adviser. As a tool it is certainly useful, as long as it sits in the right place:

  • Filling the blank page: structuring questions and preparing a first draft for the conversation with the tax adviser.
  • Explaining terms: what is the small business scheme, what is depreciation? For understanding, not for binding information.
  • Pre-sorting receipts and putting documents in order before they go to the adviser.
  • But: no sensitive data in unvetted tools, cross-check every output, and leave the binding advice to the person who is liable for it.

The AI brings the most value where it supports the human. Anyone who comes to the tax adviser with a prepared draft and ordered receipts saves the adviser’s time and therefore real money, and the advice gets better because the right questions are already on the table. This way round the order is right: first the tool, then the professional who decides and answers for it.

For companies that use such tools, this is a question of governance. A management system in accordance with ISO/IEC 42001 requires exactly that: a clearly defined purpose, defined objectives for responsible use, among which the standard counts human oversight, and the rule on which data may go into which tool at all. AI proposes, the human decides and takes responsibility.

That is not hostility to technology, on the contrary. It is the same order I know from the workshop: the tool makes the work easier, but the master craftsman sets the standard and bears the responsibility. In tax the master is called the tax adviser, and the AI is the new file, not the new master.

AI does not replace a tax adviser. At best it replaces the blank page. Advice, liability and confidentiality stay with the human who answers for them.

My clear position: in tax, convenience and responsibility part ways particularly sharply. A tax tip from the AI is quickly obtained, but if it is wrong, you sit alone at the tax office, not the AI. Use the tool for preparation, for understanding and for the blank page. For the decision you sign, you need someone who is liable for it with their name. That is exactly what the professional reservation is for.

Are you using AI in your company and unsure which data may go into which tool and where human control must sit? Check in a few minutes whether your use of AI is properly set up.

To the AI readiness check
Share: LinkedIn E-Mail

Frequently asked questions

May I use ChatGPT for my own tax return?+

For your own tax you may in principle use AI. It is your own affair and not covered by the professional reservation. But you then bear full responsibility: incorrect information given to the tax office is at your expense, even if the AI supplied it.

May an AI tool offer tax advice on a commercial basis?+

Commercial assistance in tax matters for third parties is permitted under the German Tax Advisory Act only to authorised persons (tax advisers, lawyers, auditors). An AI tool is not an authorised person. An offering that gives third parties tax information on a commercial basis moves at the edge of the professional reservation.

What is the biggest risk with AI tax tips?+

That the AI sounds convincing and is still wrong. Language models invent allowances, deadlines and sections. With tax, which changes annually, that is particularly dangerous, because incorrect information can be an understatement of tax.

Is it a data protection problem to enter financial data into an AI tool?+

Yes. Anyone who enters receipts, turnover or account data into a public AI tool hands sensitive data to an outside provider, often in a third country, without a contract and without confidentiality. Unlike the tax adviser, a public model is not subject to the duty of confidentiality under Section 203 of the German Criminal Code.

What can I sensibly use AI for in tax matters?+

For preparation: structuring questions, understanding terms, ordering receipts, a first draft for the conversation with the adviser. Not for binding information and not with sensitive data in unvetted tools. The advice and the liability stay with the human.

Author & expert review: Lars Zimmermann · ISO/IEC 42001 Senior Lead Auditor & Senior Lead Implementer · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor & Lead Implementer (PECB)

Last updated: 10 November 2026. Researched and reviewed to the best of our knowledge; not a substitute for individual legal advice.

Questions about your own case?

In a free 15-minute intro call we assess where you stand on ISO 42001, ISO 27001 and the EU AI Act, honestly and without a sales pitch.

Continue reading