Skip to content
All articles
Fundamentals 8 min read· by Lars Zimmermann

Stocktake or audit? Four questions to put to a proposal

More and more surveys are being called audits. Four questions show what you are really getting, and what a stocktake can still do for you all the same.

In short

An audit needs four things: a defined criterion, objective evidence instead of statements, an independent auditor and a report with classified findings. If one is missing, it is a stocktake. It can be valuable but is not evidence: a certification body will not accept it as an internal audit under ISO/IEC 42001 clause 9.2, and customers cannot rely on it.

Auf Deutsch lesen: deutsche Fassung

A conspicuous number of proposals with the word audit on them have been landing on my desk recently. A workshop with senior management. A questionnaire for the departments. A maturity model with traffic-light colours. These are all usable formats that you can seriously work with. They are just not audits, and the difference becomes expensive exactly when somebody later wants to present the result.

Why the word is migrating right now

The term audit has a ring that no other word replaces. It promises examination instead of opinion. That is why it migrates, and in the AI field it is currently migrating particularly fast, because many providers there are new and want to set their service apart from consulting.

In most cases I do not think this is intentional. Anyone who carries out a structured survey, asks systematically and documents cleanly has the subjective feeling of having audited. The difference lies neither in diligence nor in care. It lies in four characteristics that are either there or not.

A practical case from a mid-sized company shows when this tips over. A manufacturing business had commissioned a very decent survey of its AI applications: all systems recorded, responsible persons named, risks roughly assessed, at the end a presentation with traffic lights. A good paper, worth every euro. Just under a year later a major customer asked for evidence of the internal audit. The presentation was submitted. The customer wanted to know which requirement had been audited against and who had seen the evidence. There was no answer to either, because neither was ever part of the assignment. The work was not bad, it was just never meant for this purpose.

Four questions a proposal has to answer

You can put these four questions to any proposal before you sign. You do not need knowledge of the standards for this, only the willingness to insist on a clear answer.

  • Against which criterion is the audit carried out? An audit measures against something defined: a standard, a contract, a legal provision, an internal rule. If the proposal only says that the current state will be surveyed, the yardstick is missing. Without a yardstick there is no result that anyone could challenge or confirm.
  • What counts as evidence? An audit relies on objective evidence, that is on records, observations, system extracts. A statement in conversation is a pointer to where one should look, but not evidence. Simply ask: what do you look at, and do you have people show you what they claim?
  • Who audits, and what did this person previously build at your company? Anyone who helped set up a system cannot assess it independently. That is not mistrust of the person, it is a property of the constellation.
  • What is there at the end, and how are the findings classified? An audit report separates: what is a nonconformity, what an observation, what an opportunity for improvement. A colour scale without this separation says nothing about what you must remedy and what you could remedy.

If a provider answers all four questions calmly and concretely, they are probably right for you. If three of them end in general phrases, you are looking at a stocktake. That is perfectly fine, as long as that is also what it says on the invoice.

With the first question the difference is particularly audible. A weak answer sounds like best practices, the current state of the art or common requirements. A robust answer names a document you can open: ISO/IEC 42001 with clauses 4 to 10 and Annex A, the requirements from your framework agreement with a particular customer, the rules of your own AI policy in last quarter’s version. The difference is not academic: only against a named criterion can a result be wrong at all, and only what can be wrong has any value as a statement.

With the second question a simple thought experiment helps. Suppose someone claims that every AI output is approved by a human before it is sent. The stocktake records that the department reported it this way. The audit wants to see where this approval is stored: in the log, in the workflow, in the system’s role assignment. If nothing is found there, the statement is not refuted, it is merely unsubstantiated. And exactly this distinction, substantiated or unsubstantiated, is the entire difference between the two formats.

The third question is the most uncomfortable

Independence cannot be replaced by care. ISO 19011 lists it as a principle in its own right, and the fourth edition of 2026 has done something remarkable at this point: the 2018 edition still contained an express relaxation for small organisations in which full independence of internal auditors could not be achieved. This reference to size has been dropped. It now applies generally that where independence is not possible, every effort is to be made to remove bias.

The difference is finer than it sounds, and it hits practice in small and mid-sized companies precisely. The relief no longer depends on a company being small, but on independence actually being impossible. Anyone who has two people who could audit each other cannot invoke size.

For external audits, ISO/IEC 17021-1 draws the line even more sharply, and more precisely than most assume. Under it, consultancy is participation in establishing, implementing or maintaining a management system, for example preparing manuals and procedures or giving specific solutions. Expressly not consultancy, by contrast, is conveying general information, explaining the purpose of criteria, identifying opportunities for improvement or explaining methods and tools.

The line does not run between speaking and keeping silent. It runs between a general explanation and a solution tailored to your organisation.

That is the reason why I myself do not build what I later audit. Not out of a fixation on principle, but because a report becomes worthless as soon as someone can ask whether the auditor assessed their own work.

What a stocktake can really do

Now the part that is usually missing from texts like this. A stocktake is not an inferior audit. It is a different tool, and for getting started often the better one.

A gap analysis, for example, compares your actual state with the requirements and delivers a prioritised list: fulfilled, partly fulfilled, open. It is faster, cheaper and lower-risk than an audit, it may make recommendations, and it may rely on statements because it does not have to prove anything. That is exactly why it gives you robust project planning in one to three weeks, which an audit is not designed for at all.

An audit, by contrast, looks backwards. It establishes whether something that already exists demonstrably works. Anyone who has not yet built anything gets from an audit a long list of nonconformities and not a single usable next step. Letting an audit loose on an empty organisation is wasted money.

The honest sequence is therefore almost always: first the stocktake, then build, then the audit. Anyone who calls the first stage an audit is not selling anything worse, they are just using the word for something that will still be needed later.

What the wrong label costs

As long as nobody wants to see the report, the difference goes unnoticed. It is noticed in four places, and all four come later, when it is inconvenient.

  • In the internal audit: ISO/IEC 42001 requires in clause 9.2 that the organisation conducts internal audits at planned intervals, and in 9.2.2 calls for an audit programme together with a record of the results. A stocktake does not fulfil that, and the certification body sees it immediately in the stage 1 audit.
  • In the management review: top management is supposed to decide, among other things, on audit results. Anyone who presents a survey to it as an audit result is building the decision on a basis that is not one.
  • In the supply chain: when your customer asks for the evidence, they check which criterion was audited against and who audited. A report without both does not hold up in their own audit programme.
  • In external communication: advertising with a result that is described as an audit without being one is a statement about a characteristic of your own service. Competitors and associations see such things, and in case of doubt it is a misleading commercial practice.

If you now have such a report in the drawer, nothing is lost. Do not throw it away, it is a usable basis. You only need the second step: define the criterion to be audited against, follow up the evidence for the most important statements and appoint someone who is not responsible for the area concerned. In a manageable time a good survey becomes an audit this way. The reverse does not work: a criterion cannot be talked into a report after the fact.

Where the terms come from

Anyone who wants to look it up will find the building blocks in one place. ISO 19011 defines audit criteria, audit evidence and audit findings as separate terms, and this trio is the real answer to the question of what makes an audit an audit: you compare evidence with criteria and call the result a finding.

A note for everyone quoting from older documents: the numbering shifted with the 2026 edition. Audit evidence is now under 3.10, audit findings under 3.11. In the 2018 edition, 3.10 was still audit findings. Anyone who copies an old reference is therefore citing the wrong term, and of all people it is the one who opens the standard themselves who notices.

For independence, clause 4 of ISO 19011 is relevant, for external certification audits additionally ISO/IEC 17021-1 with the clauses on impartiality and on the separation of consultancy and audit. ISO 19011 does not establish an obligation to carry out internal audits. That is in the respective management system standard, so for AI management systems in ISO/IEC 42001 clause 9.2.

And if you only want to ask one question instead of four: have them tell you which criterion will be audited against. Anyone without a concrete answer to that will not be able to answer the other three either.

Share: LinkedIn E-Mail

Frequently asked questions

Is a gap analysis an audit?+

No. A gap analysis compares the actual state with requirements, may rely on statements and may give recommendations. An audit collects objective evidence, is carried out independently and ends with classified findings. Both make sense, just at different points in time: first the stocktake, then build, then the audit.

How can I tell from a proposal what I am getting?+

From four points: the audit criterion named, the type of evidence, the independence of the person auditing and the form of the result. If the proposal names no criterion and announces traffic lights instead of findings, it is a stocktake. Ask before you sign, not afterwards.

May someone audit my system who helped build it?+

For an internal audit the rule is: where independence is not possible, every effort must be made to remove bias. ISO 19011 deleted the earlier relaxation for small organisations in 2026; the only decisive factor now is whether independence is actually impossible. For external certification audits the separation of consultancy and audit is mandatory anyway.

Does a stocktake count as the internal audit under ISO 42001?+

No. Clause 9.2 requires internal audits at planned intervals, plus an audit programme and recorded results under 9.2.2. A survey without criterion, evidence and findings does not fulfil that and will be noticed at the latest in the certification body’s stage 1 audit.

Is the term audit legally protected?+

The word itself is not protected, anyone may call their service that. But anyone who advertises a result as an audit that does not have the characteristics of an audit is making a statement about the properties of their service. That can be a misleading commercial practice, and warning letters can be issued by competitors, registered trade and consumer associations and chambers (Section 8(3) of the German Act against Unfair Competition, UWG). Customers themselves have no claim to injunctive relief.

Author & expert review: Lars Zimmermann · ISO/IEC 42001 Senior Lead Auditor & Senior Lead Implementer · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor & Lead Implementer (PECB)

Last updated: 10 November 2026. Researched and reviewed to the best of our knowledge; not a substitute for individual legal advice.

Questions about your own case?

In a free 15-minute intro call we assess where you stand on ISO 42001, ISO 27001 and the EU AI Act, honestly and without a sales pitch.

Continue reading