Skip to content
All articles
Audit practice 8 min read· by Lars Zimmermann

Your auditor demands something that is not in the standard

A certificate for internal auditors, everything audited every three years: two common demands are not in ISO 9001. How to settle the matter politely.

In short

Ask for the reference: in exactly which clause the demand is stated. Two examples do not stand up to that. The word certificate does not appear a single time in ISO 9001, and the standard does not know a three-year cycle for all areas either. That cycle comes from IATF 16949, the automotive scheme.

Auf Deutsch lesen: deutsche Fassung

Update of 10 November 2026. Two things. First, ISO 9001:2026 has applied since September 2026. The references have shifted: the selection of auditors is now in 9.2.2 b), the requirements for the audit programme are in the introductory sentences of 9.2.2. Nothing changes in substance, the word certificate and a three-year period do not appear in the new edition either. Second, IATF 16949 now speaks of a three-year audit cycle in clause 9.2.2.2 instead of three calendar years.

There is a moment in the audit that almost everyone knows: the auditor demands something that nobody has ever demanded before, and everyone in the room nods. Nobody asks, because nobody is sure. The nod becomes an action, the action becomes a procedure, and three years later the company is doing something that is in no standard. I have brought two demands that are made particularly often, and neither stands up to the cross-check.

The sentence that settles the matter in ten seconds

It is: in which clause exactly is that stated? Not in which standard, not in essence, but the clause. That is not a provocation, nor a vote of no confidence. It is the normal way an audit works, because under ISO 19011, term 3.11, a finding is the result of the evaluation of evidence against audit criteria. No criterion, no finding. Whoever asks for the reference is asking for the criterion.

Good auditors are happy to answer this question. They have the clause in their head or look it up, and after that the matter is settled in two minutes, one way or the other. If instead you get a sentence like “everyone does it that way” or “the certification body requires it”, you know enough: the demand has no yardstick, and it cannot become a nonconformity.

The tone matters. The question works when it is friendly and interested, not combative. I usually phrase it like this: I want to write this down correctly, in which clause do I find it? That gives the other person a bridge, and you get either the reference or the realisation that there is none.

After that the answer sorts itself. These three hold, and you should then implement the demand:

  • Clause 9.2.2 c), that is about the selection of auditors.
  • It is in your own procedure QM-07, section 3.
  • It comes from the framework agreement with your customer, appendix 4.

And these three do not hold, no matter how convincingly they are delivered:

  • That is established practice, everyone does it that way.
  • Our certification body requires that internally.
  • That follows from the spirit and purpose of the standard.

Example one: the certificate for the internal auditor

The demand is that internal auditors must be able to show a training course with a certificate. It is so widespread that entire training offerings are built on it. Only it is not in the standard. The word certificate does not appear a single time in ISO 9001:2015. I counted in the full text: zero hits. The same goes for the German edition of ISO/IEC 42001, by the way: zero.

What is actually required is stated in two places. Clause 7.2 says the organisation must determine the necessary competence and ensure that the persons are competent on the basis of appropriate education, training or experience. The small word in between is an or, not an and. And it must retain documented information as evidence of competence, that is, evidence, not a diploma. Clause 9.2.2 c) requires something quite different for audits, namely that auditors are selected so that objectivity and the impartiality of the audit process are ensured.

That is the real hurdle, and it is harder than any certificate: nobody audits their own area. A training course changes nothing about that. An experienced production manager who has known for twenty years where the bodies are buried, and who audits purchasing, fulfils both requirements. A freshly certified colleague who audits his own department fulfils neither.

The training course is a good route to competence. It is not the requirement. The requirement is the competence itself, and you can evidence that in other ways too.

Do not misread this as a plea against training. I train auditors myself and consider the course the fastest route. But there is a difference between recommending something and claiming that the standard requires it. The latter is simply wrong, and it costs small companies money that they need more urgently elsewhere.

Example two: everything must be audited every three years

The second demand sounds even more plausible: within three years all processes and all areas must have been audited once. Many audit programmes in SMEs are built exactly like that, as a matrix with ticks, and nobody asks where the three years come from. They do not come from ISO 9001. Here too I counted: neither “three years” nor “3 years” appears anywhere in the text of the standard.

What clause 9.2.2 a) requires is an audit programme with frequency, methods, responsibilities, planning requirements and reporting. And then the clause names three things that must be taken into consideration: the importance of the processes concerned, changes affecting the organisation and the results of previous audits. That is a risk-based requirement, not a calendar requirement. A process that has been running inconspicuously for five years and has not changed may come up less often than the one in which there were three nonconformities last year.

A case from a machining company with just under sixty employees that I supported: the audit programme contained eleven areas, neatly spread over three years. In one year two of them dropped out, because a customer triggered a special inspection and the time was needed elsewhere. The quality manager feared a nonconformity and wanted to rush the two audits through in December, two half days, without preparation, just so that the ticks were there. We did not do it. Instead, the audit programme contained a line on why the plan was changed and which processes were brought forward in exchange. The certification auditor read it, nodded and turned the page. Two audits that would have been of use to nobody did not take place as a result.

The three-year period is nevertheless not invented. It is in IATF 16949, the automotive industry’s scheme, there in clause 9.2.2.2: on the basis of an annual programme, all processes of the quality management system are to be audited within a three-year audit cycle. Whoever comes from the automotive world often carries this rule along unconsciously. For a supplier with an IATF certificate it is binding. For the machine builder next door who is only certified to ISO 9001, it is not.

That does not mean you now have to rebuild your audit programme. A three-year rotation is a clean, traceable plan and exactly right for many companies. It only means: you do it because you consider it sensible, not because the standard requires it. And if next year one area comes up twice because something went wrong there, and another drops out as a result, that is not a breach of the rules, but exactly what 9.2.2 a) describes.

Why this happens, and why it is mostly not ill will

There are three sources for such demands, and none of them is malice. I have just described the first: rules from another scheme that someone brings along. Automotive, aviation, medical devices, food. Whoever moves in several worlds has more requirements in their head than apply to your case.

The second source is old versions. ISO 9001 deleted a number of things in the 2015 revision, including the mandatory quality manual and the management representative. Whoever learned before 2015 and has not read up since continues to demand both. I still hear this regularly today.

The third source is customer requirements that appear as requirements of the standard. A large customer writes something into its supplier requirements that mutates over the years into a supposed standard. This third source is the most interesting, because here the demand is often actually binding, only on the basis of the contract.

For you as the auditee, the origin changes nothing about the question. It is always the same: where is that stated? Only the answer decides whether you have to do it, want to do it or do not do it at all.

The flip side: sometimes it is in there after all, just somewhere else

Now the part that saves this article from becoming a guide to being right. In many cases the auditor is right, and the reference is simply not where you are looking. Under ISO 19011, term 3.8, audit criteria explicitly include, alongside requirements of standards, policies, procedures, work instructions, legal requirements and contractual obligations. And for certification audits, ISO/IEC 17021-1 prescribes in clause 9.2.1.4 that the audit criteria must include the processes and documents developed by the client itself.

In plain terms: if your own procedure says that internal auditors attend a training course, then that applies. Not because ISO 9001 requires it, but because you required it. The same mechanism applies to your three-year rotation: as soon as it is in your audit programme, it is your own stipulation, and an area that dropped out is a nonconformity against your own planning.

That is why the question about the reference always has two possible outcomes, and both are valuable. Either the demand has no yardstick, in which case it is dealt with. Or it has one, and in the process you learn what you once wrote down for yourselves. In half of the cases I have experienced it was the latter, and nobody in the room knew about it.

For AI management systems this applies one to one. ISO/IEC 42001 formulates in clause 9.2.2 the same selection rule for auditors as ISO 9001, namely objectivity and impartiality, and in 7.2 the same competence rule with education, training or experience. Because the subject is new and everyone currently has something to say about it, however, the likelihood is higher here that a demand is put to you that is stated nowhere. The cross-check is the same, and it still takes ten seconds.

A final note in case the demand ends up in the report as a nonconformity anyway: every certification body has an appeals procedure, and using it is not an affront. All you need for it is the sentence that you cannot find the reference, and the request to name it. Whoever works properly names it or withdraws the finding.

Share: LinkedIn E-Mail

Frequently asked questions

Does an internal auditor need a certificate under ISO 9001?+

No. The word certificate does not appear a single time in the text of the standard. Clause 7.2 requires the organisation to determine the necessary competence and ensure that the persons are competent on the basis of appropriate education, training or experience, and to retain documented information as evidence of competence. Clause 9.2.2 c) additionally requires objectivity and impartiality, which in practice means: nobody audits their own area. A training course is a good route to that, but not an obligation.

Do all areas have to be audited within three years?+

Not under ISO 9001. Clause 9.2.2 a) requires an audit programme that takes into consideration the importance of the processes concerned, changes affecting the organisation and the results of previous audits; that is risk-based and names no time limit. The three-year period is in IATF 16949, clause 9.2.2.2, and therefore applies to companies with an IATF certificate. Whoever is only certified to ISO 9001 may plan their programme by risk.

How do I dispute a nonconformity without annoying the auditor?+

By asking for the reference instead of the reasoning. A wording that almost always works: I want to write this down correctly, in which clause do I find it? That is a factual question about the audit criterion, and without a criterion there is, under ISO 19011, term 3.11, no finding at all. If no answer comes, the certification body’s appeals procedure is additionally open to you.

What if the demand is in our own documentation?+

Then it applies. ISO 19011 explicitly lists policies, procedures, work instructions and contractual obligations in the definition of audit criteria, and ISO/IEC 17021-1 even obliges the certification body in clause 9.2.1.4 to use the processes and documents developed by the client itself as a criterion. Your own stipulation is therefore auditable, even if the standard does not require it.

Author & expert review: Lars Zimmermann · ISO/IEC 42001 Senior Lead Auditor & Senior Lead Implementer · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor & Lead Implementer (PECB)

Last updated: 10 November 2026. Researched and reviewed to the best of our knowledge; not a substitute for individual legal advice.

Questions about your own case?

In a free 15-minute intro call we assess where you stand on ISO 42001, ISO 27001 and the EU AI Act, honestly and without a sales pitch.

Continue reading